Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you buy something through one, Naturally Well Today may earn a small commission, and the price you pay does not change. How this works.
Every home seems to have one. A closet, a drawer, a corner of a room that gets closed off rather than dealt with. Mine was a hall closet, the kind that catches whatever does not have another home yet. Coats that no longer fit anyone. A vacuum attachment for a vacuum I no longer own. Bags of bags. For years I opened it only far enough to shove one more thing in, then closed it quickly before anything could fall out.
I want to write about this one honestly, because most of what gets written about clearing out a space skips past the part where you avoid it for a long time first. That avoidance is not a failure. It is often just a sign that the task feels bigger than it actually is.
Why this closet was harder than the others
The kitchen cabinets I had already cleared out had a kind of built-in structure. Dishes, containers, gadgets, each with an obvious category. The hall closet had no such structure. It held whatever did not belong anywhere else, which meant every single item required its own small decision, with no shortcut of sorting by type.
That is, I think, the real reason closets like this get avoided. Not because the task is physically hard, but because it asks for more individual decisions in a shorter space than almost anywhere else in the house.
Setting a much smaller goal
The thing that finally got the door open was lowering what counted as success. I did not tell myself I would clear the closet. I told myself I would take out five things and decide what happened to each one. Just five. If I wanted to stop after that, I could.
Some evenings that is exactly what happened. Five things, then the door closed again, this time with five fewer things behind it. Other evenings, once I had started, I kept going longer than planned. But the low bar of five things is what got me to open the door in the first place, again and again, until eventually there was not much left inside it.
- A coat that had not fit in three years, given to a donation box
- A box of cables for devices I no longer owned, recycled at a local electronics drop-off
- Three tote bags kept for no clear reason, reduced to one
- A broken umbrella, thrown away rather than kept for parts that would never get used
- An old vacuum attachment, gone along with the vacuum it belonged to
The bag of bags
I want to mention this specifically because I suspect it is common. A bag full of other bags, kept in case one was ever needed. I kept far more than I ever used. Going through them, I set aside a reasonable number, maybe eight or ten, for actual reuse, and let the rest go to a store drop-off box that accepts them for recycling. The closet immediately felt less crowded, out of proportion to how much space that one bag of bags had actually taken up.
The closet did not need a system. It needed permission to be worked on slowly, five things at a time.
What I learned about the things I kept
Not everything left. A box of holiday decorations stayed, because it gets used every year and has an obvious place to belong for eleven months out of twelve. A spare set of sheets stayed, because guests do occasionally need them. The point was never to empty the closet completely. It was to make sure everything left inside it had an actual reason to be there, rather than just having nowhere else to go.
I think this distinction matters. A closet that holds things you use, even if you use them rarely, is doing its job. A closet that holds things because they have nowhere else to go and nobody has decided what to do with them is a different situation entirely, and that is the one worth working through.
Why I am glad I did not rush it
If I had tried to do this closet in one sitting, the way I once tried to do a kitchen cabinet, I think I would have made worse decisions near the end, tired and wanting to be finished. Doing it across several weeks, five things at a time, meant every decision got made with roughly the same amount of attention as the one before it. Nothing got rushed out just because I was tired of looking at it.
If you have a closet like this
I would not suggest opening it with the goal of finishing. I would suggest opening it with the goal of taking out five things tonight. That is a small enough task that there is no good reason to keep avoiding it, and it tends to be enough to get the process moving on its own.
